Skip to main content

Pizza in New Baltimore

Crispy oven-baked pizza is available at Alexanders Deli Diner in New Baltimore, MI, with pickup offered for your pizza order.

Order online

Pizza to Try

“You’ve gotta try the pizza at Alexander’s Deli. It’s new to their menu!! Ordered the vegetarian last night. It was amazing. Great addition to your menu! Good job Milt 👍🏼👏‼️. The words out now 😂🍕‼️”

“Excellent home cooked meals & friendly service. Prices are very reasonable. No one is a stranger here. The new pizza offering is excellent & makes it a great place for groups to gather.”

Something for Everyone at Alexanders Deli Diner

At Alexanders Deli Diner, pizza begins with fresh homemade dough and handcrafted pizza sauce. Those two preparations form the base of the baked pizza you can enjoy in New Baltimore, MI.

Alexanders Pizza is baked to a crispy finish in a slow-burning pizza oven at Alexanders Deli Diner in New Baltimore, MI, where you can order this oven-baked pizza for your next lunch or dinner.

Visit or order in New Baltimore, MI for pickup, dine-in, or delivery. For your pizza order, choose the large size with 6–8 pieces or the extra-large size with 8–10 pieces to share at your table.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular pizza options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

  • Alexanders Pizza — Choose a large or extra-large pizza, made with fresh dough and hand-crafted sauce, then baked in a slow-burning oven.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for pizza throughout the New Baltimore area. Order your pizza online for convenient pickup or delivery.