Italian Food in New Baltimore

Homemade sauces and oven-baked pizza shape Italian food at Alexanders Deli Diner in New Baltimore, MI, available for pickup.

Order online

Italian Food to Try

Alexanders Pizza

Fresh dough, handcrafted sauce, and crisp baking define this slow-oven pizza.

Pepperoni, Ham & Mushroom Pizza$15.95Large pizza topped with pepperoni, ham, and mushrooms on homemade dough with hand-crafted pizza sauce.
Italian Sausage Pizza$19.45Extra-large pizza topped with Italian sausage on homemade dough with hand-crafted pizza sauce.
Spinach, Tomato & Olive Pizza$15.95Large vegetarian pizza topped with spinach, tomatoes, and black olives on homemade dough with pizza sauce.
Ham & Pineapple Pizza$20.95Extra-large pizza topped with ham and pineapple on homemade dough with hand-crafted pizza sauce.
Pepperoni & Mushroom Pizza$20.95Extra-large pizza topped with pepperoni and mushrooms on homemade dough with hand-crafted pizza sauce.
Pepperoni, Sausage & Green Pepper Pizza$16.95Large pizza topped with pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, and green peppers on homemade dough with pizza sauce.

“You’ve gotta try the pizza at Alexander’s Deli. It’s new to their menu!! Ordered the vegetarian last night. It was amazing. Great addition to your menu! Good job Milt 👍🏼👏‼️. The words out now 😂🍕‼️”

“Excellent home cooked meals & friendly service. Prices are very reasonable. No one is a stranger here. The new pizza offering is excellent & makes it a great place for groups to gather.”

Chicken Parmesan Dinner

$13.50

Marinated chicken with meat sauce, Parmesan, spaghetti, and garlic bread.

Fettuccine Alfredo Dinner

$13.50

Fettuccine in creamy homemade Alfredo sauce with garlic bread.

A Taste of Alexanders Deli Diner

Italian food at Alexanders Deli Diner ranges from chicken and spaghetti to fettuccine and pizza. The dinners include garlic bread, while the pizza is baked in a slow-burning oven for a crispy finish.

Chicken Parmesan Dinner has marinated breast and meat sauce; Fettuccine Alfredo Dinner pairs noodles with creamy homemade sauce. Alexanders Pizza uses homemade dough and hand-crafted pizza sauce.

Visit Alexanders Deli Diner in New Baltimore, MI, for pickup, dine-in, or delivery. Choose Large (6-8 Pieces) or Extra Large (8-10 Pieces) pizza; add chicken or shrimp to your Alfredo for an extra charge.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular Italian food options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

Alexanders Pizza — Choose a large or extra-large pizza, made with fresh dough and hand-crafted sauce, then baked in a slow-burning oven.
Chicken Parmesan Dinner — Two marinated chicken breast pieces are topped with meat sauce and Parmesan, served with spaghetti, garlic bread, and a required side choice.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for italian food throughout the New Baltimore area. Order your italian food online for convenient pickup or delivery.